If you're seeing this, you're deliberately surfing with CSS off (as I've been known to do), or you're using an old browser (in which case you might consider upgrading your browser.)

Sunday, December 11, 2005

While I've been getting tired of reading Ellis Peters' Brother Cadfael novels, when some adaptations showed up on BBC7, I figured I'd give them a try. It's the repetitiveness of the plots that's been annoying me, not the characters, and an audio format usually gives me a clearer idea of the characters. (It's true that it also gives me the time to think about the clues that are given or omitted. However, I have no objections to this adaptation on those grounds.)

I recorded three of them, but listened to Monk's Hood first, as it came earliest in the chronology. This starred Philip Madoc as Cadfael, who has a nice deep strong voice; the recurring secondary characters of Brother Mark and Hugh Beringar were also voiced well and suitably. My only complaint is that the dialogue was occasionally a touch too fast; there were times when I thought a slight pause between speakers would have suited the content, but the responses came disconcertingly fast. Otherwise, this was an enjoyable listen, and I'll keep the others for commutes when I can't deal with anything more demanding.

(Weird note of the day: Something about the Welsh accents in this production (maybe the rhythm?) reminds me of—of all things—Indian accents.)


Comments:

#1 :: Jen Birren wrote on December 12, 2005 at 11:40 AM:

Welsh accents: this is a Known Issue- it's almost a stock joke about bad impressionists that they slip between Welsh and Indian. It's the rhythm, as you say, and also some of the intonations.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/4328733.stm has a BBC journalist trying to track down some linguists to explain it.


#2 :: Kate wrote on December 12, 2005 at 12:04 PM:

Jen, thanks for the link and the note--it's good to know that the similiarity isn't just a weird quirk of my ears.


#3 :: Jean wrote on December 14, 2005 at 5:25 AM:

Apparently the explanation that it relates to the role of Welsh missionaries in the Indian subcontinent is an urban myth


Subscribe to comments on this post: RSS feed


Post a comment:




(HTML permitted for links and formatting):

Remember Me?


« Christie, Agatha: Body in the Library, The... | Main | Christie, Agatha: Mirror Crack'd from Side to... »


Main
About
ROT-13

Change Page Style

Search: (advanced)

Browse:

By Category:

By Recent Comments:

By Entry: Random, All

By Date (text list):

Syndicate: